Aj Gould key questionsThis is a featured page

These are key questions in understanding the “The Geometer of Race” article..

Folks- these are a good set of answers that will be useful for your individual analysis for your ARP, Essay, and PWT - Owen, October 17.


1. What are the two main reasons that Blumenbach gave for naming the ‘Western’ racial group after the Caucasian mountains?

First main reason is that the most beautiful people came from this small western region. Secand main reason is the prospect that humans, homo sapiens, first developed in Caucas mountains area. (Risa)

First reason is the maximal beauty of people from this small region. Second reason is the probability that humans were first created in this area. (Hajime)

Good answers - Owen

2. How did the addition of the ‘Malay’ race alter Linnaeus’ system?

The addition of the Malay race changed the concept of Linnaeus' system from a flat, geographically based model to a geometry of human order based on beauty and distance - distance from the Causcus Mountains and Caucasians as the most beautiful race. [Aya]

Blumenbach changed the geometry of human order from a geographically based model without any ranking to a hierarchy of worth based on beauty and distance from the Caucasian ideal. (Yuki) (Owen)

3. What criteria did Linnaeus use to distinguish between races?

Linnaeus defined four groups of human races both by geography (and appearance- No not appearance, Owen). (Fumiko)

He divided all humans into four groups based on beauty (skin of color) and place of origin. (Tatsuya) (Only place of origin, not beauty - Owen)

Please see p. 144, Lines 9-11 (Owen)

4. What are the formal titles given to Linnaeus’ and Blumenbach’s taxonomies?

Please see p. 141 & p. 143 (Owen)

5. What evidence did Blumenbach cite to support his theory that all humans originated from the same species?
Blumenbach claimed that Homo sapiens were created in a single region and had then spread over the globe. (Eri) Further Blumenbach claimed that human beings have adapted to live in various environments, and most racial variations can be easily changed, and do not define any group as separate - humans are one and the same species (Satoko-K) (Owen)

6. What did Blumenbach mean by ‘degenerations’?

First, he claimed that "Homo sapiens had been created in a single region then spread around the world. Changes in characteristics or "degenerations" arose from different modes of life arising from differences in climate and habitat. (melody)
(Owen)

7. What evidence does Gould cite to illustrate that Blumenbach was not racist in his thinking?

Gould cited that Blumenbach held particularly strong opinions on the equal status of black Africans and white Europeans. Blumenbach campaigned for the abolition of slavery and asserted the moral superiority of slaves to their captors. (kayo)

8. What is the final point that Gould makes in this article, his conclusion?

He argues that scholars' ideas do not reside in the ivory towers of universities. As evidence, he mentions that Blumenbach's ideas have had great influence on wars, social upheavals, our sufferings, and hopes. (Satsuki)

9. In your text, draw and label a diagram below to represent Blumenbach’s Model.


okoj
okoj
Latest page update: made by okoj , Nov 18 2006, 9:46 PM EST (about this update About This Update okoj Edited by okoj

4 words added
4 words deleted

view changes

- complete history)
Keyword tags: gould
More Info: links to this page
There are no threads for this page.  Be the first to start a new thread.

Related Content

  (what's this?Related ContentThanks to keyword tags, links to related pages and threads are added to the bottom of your pages. Up to 15 links are shown, determined by matching tags and by how recently the content was updated; keeping the most current at the top. Share your feedback on Wetpaint Central.)